A retranslation based on an original translation by W. H. S. Jones, 1918 (Scroll 2 with H.A. Ormerod), containing some of the footnotes added by Jones.
This retranslation is by Gregory Nagy | 2018.07.27*
Scroll I. Attica
{1.13.3} hang up, Pyrrhos did, taking them from the bold Gauls [Galatai],
having destroyed the entire army of Antigonos. No big wonder [thauma],
since the Aiakidai are masters of the spear, even now as also in the past.
and they brought slavery upon the Greeks [Hellēnes].
Now ownerless they lie by the columns of the temple [nāos] of Zeus,
spoils from boastful Macedonia.
Demeter, when she first created revealed [phainein] the fruit-of-the-harvest [karpos] that comes in the season of harvesting.
It is the sacred [hierē] fig-tree [sukē], that is what the generation of mortals [thnētoi] have have given it as a name. [140]
Whence Phytalos and his lineage have received honors immortal.
Scroll II. Corinth
Rich in flocks, for the god vouchsafed him wealth in abundance.
The story told at the mysteries of the Mother about Hermes and the ram I know but do not relate. After the image of Hermes come Poseidon, Leukothea, and Palaimon on a dolphin.
Daughter of Asopos, the swift, deep-eddying river,
Having conceived of Zeus and Epopeus, shepherd of peoples. [158]
Homer traces their descent to the more august side of their family, and says that they were the first founders of Thebes, in my opinion distinguishing the lower city from the Kadmeia.
When they had lost their power there came upon them an earthquake, which almost depopulated their city and took from them many of their famous sights. It damaged also the cities of Caria and Lycia, and the island of Rhodes was very violently shaken, so that it was thought that the Sibyl had had her utterance about Rhodes [160] fulfilled.
Also to mighty Eumolpos, to Keleus, leader of peoples,
Cult of the holy rites, to them all her mystery telling.
Driving away the male, and wins great glory in Argos,
Many an Argive woman will tear both cheeks in her sorrow.
Such are the words of the oracle referring to the exploit of the women.
The god in the sea, also, is called Zeus by Aeschylus, the son of Euphorion. So whoever made the image made it with three eyes, as signifying that this same god rules in all the three ‘allotments’ of the Universe, as they are called.
Pythō, too, the holy, and Taenarum swept by the high winds.
At any rate, there is a holy sanctuary of Poseidon here, and it is served by a maiden priestess until she reaches an age fit for marriage.
Scroll III. Laconia
Ruled as king, and enjoyed familiar converse with great Zeus.
Never let thy sound limbs give birth to a kingdom that lame is.
Too long then shalt thou lie in the clutches of desperate hardships;
Turmoil of war shall arise, o’erwhelming men in its billows.”
It was founded by Helios [Hĕlios not Hēlios], the youngest of the sons of Perseus, and the Dorians afterwards reduced it by siege. Its inhabitants became the first slaves of the Lacedaemonian state, and were the first to be called Helots [heilōtes], as in fact heilōtesthey were. The slaves afterwards acquired, although they were Dorians of Messenia, also came to be called Helots, just as the entire lineage of people who were called Hellēnes [‘Greeks’] were named after the region in Thessaly once called Hellas.
Plunge, to behold the old man of the sea and the home of your father.
Here is also a gate called the Gate of Castor (Kastor), and on the citadel have been built a temple and image of Athena.
Not that Pindar said his name was Pyrrhikos; that is a statement of the men of Malea.
Scroll IV. Messenia
in the dwelling of Ortilokhos.”
By the dwelling of Ortilokhos he meant the city of Pherai in Messene, and explained this himself in the visit of Peisistratos to Menelaos:
son of Ortilokhos.”
Aristomenes then in my view belongs to the time of the second war, and I will relate his history when I come to this.
To this town they withdrew, extending the old circuit to form a sufficient protection for them all. The place was strong in other respects, for Ithome falls short of none of the mountains within the Isthmus in height and at this point was most difficult to climb.
At the time Aristodemos and the seers were at a loss to interpret the saying, but in a few years the god was like to reveal it and bring it to fulfillment.
That they were compelled to share their mourning, he shows by the following:
He reckons winters and summers, by ‘green herbs’ meaning the green wheat or the time just before harvest.
Hard it is for a man forsworn to hide from God.
Hail, king Zeus, and keep Arcadia safe.”
I have discovered that Bacis also told in what manner Eira would be captured, and this too is one of his oracles:
I think that he wrote the lines because he knew that they held a musical contest.
Scroll V. Elis, Part 1
About the baleful death of the Molionidai.
This oracle proved the salvation of Pisa. To Phyleus Hēraklēs gave up the land of Elis and all the rest, more out of respect for Phyleus than because he wanted to do so: he allowed him to keep the prisoners, and Augeias to escape punishment.
Over against Trinakria, where the mouth of Alpheios bubbles
Mingling with the springs of broad Arethousa.
For this reason, therefore, because the water of the Alpheios mingles with the Arethousa, I am convinced that the story arose of the river’s love-affair.
The Lacedaemonians and their allies dedicated it,
A gift taken from the Argives, Athenians, and Ionians,
The tithe offered for victory in war.
This battle I also mentioned in my write-up [sun-graphē] of Attica. Then I described the tombs that are in Athens.
From Athens.
There is also Hermes bringing to Alexander the son of Priam the goddesses of whose beauty he is to judge, the inscription on them being:
Concerning their beauty, Hērā, Athena and Aphrodite.
On what account Artemis has wings on her shoulders I do not know; in her right hand she grips a leopard, in her left a lion. Ajax too is represented dragging Cassandra from the statue [agalma] of Athena, and by him is also an inscription: Ajax of Lokris is dragging Cassandra from Athena.
I, who once was a column in the house of Oinomaos;
Now by Kronos’ son I lie with these bands upon me,
A precious thing, and the baleful flame of fire consumed me not.
In my time another incident took place, which I will relate.
Those who took the territory of the Abantes established these memorials here with the help of the gods [theoi], tithe from Thronion.
The land called Abantis and the town of Thronion in it were a part of the Thesprotian mainland over against the Ceraunian mountains.
And the boar Talthybios swung and cast into the great depth
Of the grey sea, to feed the fishes.
Such was the ancient custom. Before the feet of the Oath-god is a bronze plate, with elegiac verses inscribed upon it, the object of which is to strike fear into those who take false oaths.
Descendants of Pelops the godlike offspring of Tantalos.
Such is the inscription on the pedestal, but the name of the artist is written on the shield of Idomeneus:
This Onatas, though belonging to the Aeginetan school of sculpture, I shall place after none of the successors of Daidalos or of the Attic school.
An Arcadian of Mainalos, now of Syracuse.
Sipte seems to be a Thracian fortress and city. The Mendeans themselves are of Greek descent, coming from Ionia, and they live inland at some distance from the sea that is by the city of Ainos.
Scroll VI. Elis, Part 2
I stand, dedicated at public expense by the Samians.”
So this inscription informs us who dedicated the statue; the next is in praise of Lysander himself:
Lysander, have you won, and are famed for valor.”
Three times at Nemeā, and four times at the Isthmus near the sea;
Khilon of Patrai, son of Khilon, whom the Achaean folk
Buried for my valor when I died in battle.”
Parrhasian by birth from Arcadia.”
Honor him with sacrifices as being no longer a mortal.”
So from this time have the Astypalaians paid honors to Kleomedes as to a hero.
The son of Glaukos, and I won two Olympic victories for boxing.”
There is also a statue of Agametor of Mantineia, who beat the boys at boxing.
Argives, who learned their art from those who lived before.”
Ikkos, the son of Nikolaidas of Tarentum, won the Olympic garland in the pentathlon and afterwards is said to have become the best trainer of his day.
After winning with his horses a victory in the glorious Games of Zeus.”
And when they could not think of a contrivance to recover the statue of Theagenes, fishermen, they say, after putting out to sea for a catch of fish caught the statue in their net and brought it back to land. The Thasians set it up in its original position, and are accustomed to sacrifice to him as to a god.
Garlanded the house of the sons of Pheidolas.”
But the inscription is at variance with the Eleian records of Olympic victors. These records give a victory to the sons of Pheidolas at the sixty-eighth Festival but at no other. You may take my statements as accurate.
Their soothsayer, the scion of the god-like Melampodidai.”
For Mantios was a son of Melampos, the son of Amythaon, and he had a son, Oikles, while Klytios was a son of Alkmaion, the son of Amphiaraos, the son of Oikles. Klytios was the son of Alkmaion by the daughter of Phegeus, and he migrated to Elis because he shrank from living with his mother’s brothers, knowing that they had compassed the murder of Alkmaion.
Such were his words, and Alexander, finding no way to counter the trick, and bound by the compulsion of his oath, unwillingly pardoned the people of Lampsacus.
After they had taken the fortress of Aratos.
Their leader was Miltiades.”
There stands also a box-wood image of Apollo with its head plated with gold. The inscription says that it was dedicated by the people of Lokris who live near the Western Cape, and that the artist was Patrokles of Kroton, the son of Catillus.
He made me, Kleoitas the son of Aristokles.”
It is said that after Kleoitas some further device was added to the mechanism by Aristeides.
Alpheios, that in broad stream flows through the land of the Pylians.”
The Eleians convinced me that they are right. For the Alpheios does flow through this district, and the passage cannot refer to another Pylos. For the land of the Pylians over against the island Sphakteria simply cannot in the nature of things be crossed by the Alpheios, and, moreover, we know of no city in Arcadia named Pylos.
When the same man, the son of aegis-bearing Zeus,
Hit him in Pylus among the dead, and gave him over to pains.”
If in the expedition of Agamemnon and Menelaos against Troy, Poseidon was according to Homer an ally of the Greeks, it cannot be unnatural for the same poet to hold that Hades helped the Pylians. At any rate, it was in the belief that the god was their friend but the enemy of Hēraklēs that the Eleians made the sanctuary for him. The reason why they are accustomed to open it only once each year is, I suppose, because men too go down only once to Hades.
Comrade of Phyleides and ruler of the great-souled Epeians.”
In Cyllene is a sanctuary of Asklepios, and one of Aphrodite. But the image of Hermes, most devoutly worshipped by the inhabitants, is merely the male member upright on the pedestal.
Scroll VII. Achaea
Who shall dwell in Pagus beyond the sacred Meles.”
So they migrated of their own free will, and believe now in two Nemeses instead of one, saying that their mother is Night, while the Athenians say that the father of the goddess [422] in Rhamnus is Okeanos.
To you the reign of a Philip will be both good and evil.
The first will make you kings over cities and peoples;
The younger will lose all the honor,
Defeated by men from west and east.”
Now those who destroyed the Macedonian empire were the Romans, dwelling in the west of Europe, and among the allies fighting on their side was Attalus … who also commanded the army from Mysia, a land lying under the rising sun.
Added to the renown of his fatherland Paleia.”
This inscription should mislead nobody, although it calls the city Paleia and not Dyme. For it is the custom of Greek poets to use ancient names instead of more modern ones, just as they surname Amphiaraos and Adrastos Phoronids, and Theseus an Erechthid.
A wide wall and very beautiful, that the city might be impregnable;
And thou, Phoebus, didst tend the shambling cows with crumpled horns.”
This, it may be conjectured, is the reason for the ox skull. On the marketplace, in the open, is an image of Athena with the tomb of Patreus in front of it.
That thou didst not intentionally, through guile, obstruct my chariot.”
So it is from horsemanship that he has acquired his name, and not for any other reason.
Of the Eumenides, where the Lacedaemonians are to be thy suppliants,
When hard-pressed in war. Kill them not with the sword,
And wrong not suppliants. For suppliants are sacred and holy.”
Hence it is plain that Poseidon was equally honored at Helike and at Aigai.
They go on to say that when Peisistratos collected the poems of Homer, which were scattered and handed down by tradition, some in one place and some in another, then either he or one of his colleagues perverted the name through ignorance.
Scroll VIII. Arcadia
Black earth gave up, that the lineage of mortals might exist.”
Who will prevent you; though I do not grudge it you.”
It is said that it was in the reign of Pelasgus that the land was called Pelasgia.
And the Bear, which they also call the Wain.”
But it may be that the constellation is merely named in honor of Kallisto, since her tomb is pointed out by the Arcadians.
Sending it to her broad fatherland from divine Cyprus.”
Very soon afterwards events showed that this oracle pointed, not to the Persians, but to Philip himself.
Arkas, from whom all Arcadians are named,
In a place where meet three, four, even five roads;
Thither I bid you go, and with kind heart
Take up Arkas and bring him back to your lovely city.
There make Arkas a precinct and sacrifices.”
This place, where the tomb of Arkas is, they call Altars of the Sun.
This story proves that the deer is an animal much longer-lived even than the elephant.
And the water of Styx down-flowing.”
These verses suggest that the poet had seen the water of the Styx trickling down. Again in the list of those who came with Guneus [500] he makes the river Titaresios receive its water from the Styx.
When he sent him to Hades the gate-keeper,
To fetch out of Erebos the hound of hateful Hades,
He would never have escaped the sheer streams of the river Styx.”
In the Thelpusian territory is a river called Arsen (Male). Cross this and go on for about twenty-five stadium-lengths, when you will arrive at the ruins of the village Caus, with a sanctuary of Causian Asklepios, built on the road.
Now Onkios was, according to tradition, a son of Apollo, and held sway in Thelpusian territory around the place Oncium; the goddess has the surname Fury for the following reason.
The swift horse of Adrastos, who was of the lineage of the gods.”
In the Thebaid it is said that Adrastos fled from Thebes:
They will have it that the verses obscurely hint that Poseidon was father to Areion, but Antimakhos says that Earth was his mother:
The very first of the Danai to drive his famous horses,
Swift Caerus and Areion of Thelpusa,
Whom near the grove of Oncean Apollo
Earth herself sent up, a marvel for mortals to see.”
But he destroyed the infatuate folk, and was destroyed himself.”
“Folk” in the poetry of Homer means the common people.
In Phigaleia, the cave that hid Deo, who bare a horse,
You have come to learn a cure for grievous famine,
Who alone have twice been nomads, alone have twice lived on wild fruits.
It was Deo who made you cease from pasturing, Deo who made you pasture again
After being binders of wheat and eaters [530] of cakes,
Because she was deprived of privileges and ancient honors given by men of former times.
And soon will she make you eat each other and feed on your children,
Unless you appease her anger with libations offered by all your people,
And adorn with divine honors the nook of the cave.”
Once with the four-horse chariot, twice with the race-horse,
Hieron bestowed on thee these gifts: his son dedicated them,
Deinomenes, as a memorial to his Syracusan father.”
Who had his home in the island of Aegina.”
Onatas was contemporary with Hegias of Athens and Ageladas of Argos.
the audience of Greeks looked at Philopoimen and by their clapping signified that the song applied to him. I am told that a similar thing happened to Themistocles at Olympia, for the audience there rose to do him honor.
Many achievements by might and many by his counsels,
Philopoimen, the Arcadian spearman, whom great renown attended,
When he commanded the lances in war.
Witness are two trophies, won from the despots
Of Sparta; the swelling flood of slavery he stayed.
Wherefore did Tegea set up in stone the great-hearted son of Kraugis,
Author of blameless freedom.”
Scroll IX. Boeotia
And built towers about it, for without towers they could not
Dwell in wide-wayed Thebe, in spite of their strength.”
Homer, however, makes no mention in his poetry of Amphion’s singing, and how he built the wall to the music of his harp. Amphion won fame for his music, learning from the Lydians themselves the Lydian mode, because of his relationship to Tantalos, and adding three strings to the four old ones.
Who wrought a dreadful deed unwittingly,
Marrying her son, who slew his father and
Wedded her. But forthwith the gods made it known among men.”
How could they “have made it known forthwith,” if Epicaste had borne four children to Oedipus? But the mother of these children was Euryganeia, daughter of Hyperphas. Among the proofs of this are the words of the author of the poem called the Oedipodia; and moreover, Onasias painted a picture at Plataea of Euryganeia bowed with grief because of the fight between her children.
Alkmene, he chose this as a chamber for himself.
Anchasian Trophonios and Agamedes made it.”
A care to me are the two sorrowful girls of Scedasus.
There a tearful battle is nigh, and no one will foretell it,
Until the Dorians have lost their glorious youth,
When the day of fate has come.
Then may Ceressus be captured, but at no other time.”
And holy Messene received at last her children.
By the arms of Thebe was Megalopolis encircled with walls,
And all Greece won independence and freedom.”
Pours on the earth peace-offerings of libation and prayer,
When Taurus is warmed by the might of the glorious sun,
Beware then of no slight disaster threatening the city;
For the harvest wastes away in it,
When they take of the earth, and bring it to the tomb of Phokos.”
If you wish blameless wealth for the country in which you live,
Bring to your homes the bones of Hector, Priam’s son,
From Asia, and reverence him as a hero, according to the bidding of Zeus.”
Later, however, it recovered its old name.
Of every sea, while he himself holds up the tall pillars,
Which keep apart earth and the sky [ouranos].
Who when the year revolved bore him a son
Oioklos, who first with the children of Aloeus founded
Ascra, which lies at the foot of Helicon, rich in springs.”
Played with great charm, and to his playing sang of beautiful Linos.” [584]
Hence some have suspected that Homer knew of older Graces as well.
Or to the great-hearted Phlegyans.”
By Ephyrians in this passage Homer means, I think, those in Thesprotis. The Phlegyan people were completely overthrown by the god with continual thunderbolts and violent earthquakes. The remnant were wasted by an epidemic of plague, but a few of them escaped to Phokis.
In the halls, because of his wife’s bed;
Leaving his home he fled from horse-breeding Argos,
And reached Minyan Orkhomenos, and the hero
Welcomed him, and bestowed on him a portion of his possessions, as was fitting.”
Late thou camest seeking offspring, but even now
To the old plough tree put a new tip.”
Obeying the oracle he took to himself a young wife, and had children, Trophonios and Agamedes.
The land of the horse-striking Minyans holds his bones,
Whose fame will rise very high in Greece
When men are judged by the touchstone of artistry.”
a line that clearly shows that even then the revenues coming to Orkhomenos were large.
Was born Aspledon in the spacious city.”
Leipephilene, like in form to the Olympian goddesses;
She bore him in the halls a son Hippotes,
And lovely Thero, like to the moonbeams.
Thero, falling into the embrace of Apollo,
Bore mighty Khairon, tamer of horses.”
Homer, I think, though he knew that Khaironeia and Lebadeia were already so called, yet uses their ancient names, just as he speaks of the river Aigyptos, not the Nile. [596]
Not that Homer was unaware of necklaces made of various materials.
With a necklace of gold strung with amber in between.”
Of gold strung with pieces of amber, like the sun.”
But Homer does not say that the necklace given to Eriphyle was of gold varied with stones. So probably the scepter is the only work of Hephaistos.
Scroll X. Phokis, Ozolian Lokris
And to both will I give victory, but more to the mortal.
refers, not to the size of Tityos, but to the place where he lay, the name of which was Nine Roods.
And with her Pyrcon, servant of the renowned Earth-shaker.
They say that afterwards Earth gave her share to Themis, who gave it to Apollo as a gift. It is said that he gave to Poseidon Kalaureia, that lies off Troizen, in exchange for his oracle.
By the sons of the Hyperboreans, Pagasus, and divine Agyieus.
After enumerating others also of the Hyperboreans, at the end of the hymn she names Olen:
And first fashioned a song of ancient verses.
Tradition, however, reports no other man as prophet but makes mention of prophetesses only.
These words, it seems to me, are but an imitation of Homer’s [606] account of the Sirens. Neither did I find the accounts agree of the way this temple disappeared. Some say that it fell into a chasm in the earth, others that it was melted by fire.
At the spoiler of Parnassus; and of his blood guilt
The Cretans shall purify his hands; but the renown shall never die.
When he won a victory at the Games of the Amphiktyones,
Singing for the Greeks tunes and lamentations.
In this way the competition in singing to the aulos [‘double-reed’] was dropped. But they added a chariot race, and Cleisthenes, the tyrant of Sikyon, was proclaimed victor in the chariot race.
by Zeus the high thunderer, whose winning-power [kratos] is the greatest.
He [= Zeus} will imposeon the warships battle and fighting,
as they are destroyed by treacherous tricks, through the baseness of the captains.
The other evidence that they quote is taken from the oracles of Musaeus:
through the baseness of their leaders, but some consolation will there be
for the defeat; they shall not escape the notice of the city but shall pay the penalty [dikē].
An immortal nymph was my mother, my father, an eater of wheat;
On my mother’s side of Idaean birth, but my fatherland was red
Marpessus, sacred to the Mother, and the river Aidoneus.
Hidden beneath this stone tomb.
A maiden once gifted with voice, but now for ever voiceless,
By hard fate doomed to this fetter.
But I am buried near the nymphs and this Hermes,
Enjoying in the world below a part of the kingdom I had then.
The Hermes stands by the side of the tomb, a square-shaped figure of stone. On the left is water running down into a well and the images of the nymphs.
Earth sends up the harvest, therefore sing the praise of Earth as Mother.
For before this, the Egyptian Hēraklēs had visited Delphi. On the occasion to which I refer, the son of Amphitryon restored the tripod to Apollo and was told by Xenocleia all he wished to know. The poets adopted the story and sing about a fight between Hēraklēs and Apollo for a tripod.
Set not within my temple. Dispatch them home speedily.
The devastating host of the Gauls shall pipe; and lawlessly
They shall ravage Asia; and much worse shall the god do
To those who dwell by the shores of the sea
For a short while. For right soon the son of Cronos
Shall raise them a helper, the dear son of a bull reared by Zeus,
Who on all the Gauls shall bring a day of destruction.
By the son of a bull, she meant Attalus, king of Pergamon, who was also styled bull-horned by an oracle.
Have come to inquire how ye shall take a city,
Come, consider what daily ration,
Drunk by the folk, saves the city which has so drunk.
For so ye may take the towered village of Phana.
The shield of a glorious man, an offering to Zeus.
I was the very first through which at this battle he thrust his left arm,
When the battle raged furiously against the Gaul.
You seek your fatherland; but no fatherland have you, only a motherland.
The island of Ios is the fatherland of your mother, which will receive you
When you have died; but be on your guard against the riddle of the young children.
The inhabitants of Ios point to Homer’s tomb in the island, and in another part to that of Clymene, who was, they say, the mother of Homer.
Whom Themisto, lady fair, shall bear in the fields, A man of renown, far from rich Salamis.
Leaving Cyprus, tossed and wetted by the waves,
The first and only poet to sing of the woes of spacious Greece,
For ever shall he be deathless and ageless.
These things I have heard, and I have read the oracles, but express no private opinion about either the age or date of Homer.
Nor yet to the place of talk, but you make long speeches here.
Painted a picture of Troy’s citadel being sacked.
For this reason then, Polygnotus too painted Kharon as a man well stricken in years.
Theseus and Peirithoös, renowned children of gods.
And in the Iliad, he has made Nestor give advice to Agamemnon and Achilles, and speaking among others the following verses:
As were Peirithoös, Dryas, shepherd of the folk,
Kaineus, Exadios, god-like Polyphemos,
And Theseus, son of Aigeus, like to the immortals.
However, it appears that Phrynichus did not elaborate the story as a man would his own invention but only touched on it as one already in the mouths of everybody in Greece.
alludes, not to a city Parapotamii (Riverside), but to the farmers beside the Kephisos.
Until on my precinct shall dash the wave
Of blue-eyed Amphitrite, roaring over the winedark sea.
So Solon induced them to consecrate to the god the territory of Cirrha, in order that the sea might become neighbor to the precinct of Apollo.